AMPONTAN

Japan from the inside out

Pyeongyang caught in another lie?

Posted by ampontan on Friday, December 21, 2007

THIS ARTICLE FROM THE WASHINGTON POST suggests that the North Koreans might have been outsmarted:

U.S. scientists have discovered traces of enriched uranium on smelted aluminum tubing provided by North Korea, apparently contradicting Pyeongyang’s denial that it had a clandestine nuclear program, according to U.S. and diplomatic sources.

The article notes the tubing could have been contaminated by exposure to other equipment, but North Korean credibility is not such that it can automatically claim it was an honest mistake. Here’s the interesting part:

David Albright, a former U.N. weapons inspector and president of the Institute for Science and International Security, said…that several Energy Department laboratories have highly sophisticated methods of detecting the nuclear material from items that had been thoroughly decontaminated.

Did the North Koreans decontaminate the tubing before submitting it to remove the evidence?

If so, it wouldn’t be the first time they’ve been caught out by advanced technology. As proof that a younger Japanese man whom they had abducted had later died while in North Korea, they submitted what they said were his cremated remains to the Japanese government.

A Japanese analysis discovered the bones were those of an old woman. Pyeongyang claimed the Japanese were lying, but it turned out they had burned the bones twice to foil identification. They were unaware that advances in technology had rendered that particular subterfuge obsolete.

How much longer does the world have to wait for their discovery that their political, governmental, and social systems are obsolete as well?

For background, here is a report from the same newspaper dated 10 November saying that the North Koreans would be providing evidence they weren’t enriching uranium. Now the possibility emerges that they were being too clever by half.

Based on the amount of space they devoted to the possibility, the Washington Post seems to have been laying the groundwork in this article to discredit Bush administration policy. Why they would take the word of Pyeongyang over Washington is another issue entirely.

Naturally, they saved the critical information for last in a 17-paragraph article.

David Albright…said in a report this year that there is “ample evidence” that North Korea was trying to put together a small-scale research program involving a few dozen centrifuges but that claims of a large-scale effort were flawed.

Albright said yesterday that the tubes acquired by North Korea needed to be cut in half and shaped in order to be used as the outer casings of centrifuges. If Pyongyang proves that the tubes were untouched, he said, it could “shatter the argument” that they were meant for a uranium program.

But Albright said it is difficult to see how North Korea could explain away a set of centrifuges that Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf said a Pakistani nuclear-smuggling network provided to Pyongyang. “I think the North Koreans are making a big mistake” if they deny they had any interest in uranium enrichment, he said. “They are going to create a lot of trouble if they stick to this.”

What trouble is created by the latest discovery remains to be seen.

NOTE: A commenter has pointed out that the bones analyzed by the Japanese government were supposedly those of Megumi Yokota, rather than a man. I regret the error.

9 Responses to “Pyeongyang caught in another lie?”

  1. Steve Schapiro said

    I’m no expert and I’m certainly no fan of North Korea, but:

    A Japanese analysis discovered the bones were those of an old woman. Pyeongyang claimed the Japanese were lying, but it turned out they had burned the bones twice to foil identification. They were unaware that advances in technology had rendered that particular subterfuge obsolete.

    Didn’t both Japanese and foreign scientists also report that such a conclusion – that the ashes were those of an old woman – was impossible?

    Is this a case in which it is at least possible that both the North Korean and Japanese governments were lying for their own political reasons?

  2. ampontan said

    I don’t know Steve. Can you provide a link?

  3. camphortree said

    Steve, you are confused with the Megumi’s returned “ash”. I am curious to know how the English magazine reporter got the idea of the possibility of the Japanese forensic medicine experts/government who were under heavy scrutiny from the populace could be “lying” in the same context of the North Korean government. Had there been a hint of the possibility that either the J-government or the Japanese forensic scientists lying, most media particulary Asahi, Mainichi, Kyodo and weekly magazines would have gleefully reported in full force.

  4. […] See also:  Ampontan’s take. […]

  5. […] views on this:You can read more from One Free Korea here.  Ampontan see similarities with North Korea’s lies with the HEU issue and their lies over kidnapped […]

  6. Lyons W said

    Sir,

    You facts are a bit confused.
    The ashes in question were not supposed to be of a man, but of Ms. Megumi Yokota herself.

    The British science journal, Nature, in February 2005, noted with scientific certainty that the Japanese testers of the ashes were simple amateurs who likely contaminated them. There is no way to conclude anything about these ashes.

    The link to the Nature article is here: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v433/n7025/full/433445a.html
    [this article is unfortunately archived and one must purchase it; maybe someone can find it elsewhere]

    A link to a Time Magazine article describe the above article is here: http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,501050404-1042508,00.html

    It is significant to those in the scientific community that the GoJ has refused to release their results, go to outside experts, and conveniently has no more ashes to test.

    The Editors of Nature were so troubled that they wrote: “Dealing with North Korea is no fun, but it doesn’t justify breaking the rules of separation between science and politics.”

  7. bender said

    Another Japan-bashing? Kind of getting tired to all the BS.

  8. Aceface said

    I too think “The Nature”article has a point on the scientific side of the argument.But they and other critics of GoJ is missing the very point.After all,”There is no way to conclude anything about these ashes.”which means Pyongyang had returned nothing that can be considered as the concrete evidence of the death of Megumi.
    Unless DPRK allows Japanese authority to investigate in their country and come to the same conclusion,the claim of the possibility of Megumi’s survival is valid.

  9. bender said

    That’s right. Why bake the bones two times? Seriously, why do some people have clouded judgments when it comes to Japan?

    Just because Koreans are spiteful of Japan, doesn’t mean they can throw BS at Japan all the time. Same goes for Japan-bashers who have no idea of the nation except for being an adversary during WWII.

Leave a comment