AMPONTAN

Japan from the inside out

The media’s anti-Japan bias: Nothing new under the sun

Posted by ampontan on Saturday, December 29, 2007

AS THE TWIG IS BENT, so grows the tree, goes the old saying, which might explain some of the recent hostility shown toward Japan from those in Britain regarding the whaling controversy.

Reports have emerged that the late Prime Minister Takeo Fukuda, father of the current prime minister, was livid over the 1970s Granada TV documentary Eastern Promise in its World in Action series produced when Hitachi wanted to open a plant in England to manufacture television sets. Mr. Fukuda even summoned the British charge d’affaires for an old-fashioned diplomatic dressing down.

Some of the problems with the program included:

  • The opening scene with an animated graphic showing a Trojan horse cut open with a samurai sword to reveal the names of Japanese companies competing with European businesses
  • An excerpt from a wartime movie showing a POW with Japanese guards (For a documentary about a factory?)
  • A scene with Americans wearing anti-Japanese T-shirts protesting at a Japanese factory. Granada TV admitted it staged the scene for the program.
  • Alleged “punishment rooms” in Japanese factories to shame workers, including a scene with a room that had distorting mirrors and dummies of the boss
  • The ending scene, in which a Japanese businessman swinging a golf club morphed into a samurai swinging a sword

Granada later said it made errors in judgement, and specifically mentioned the punishment room scene and the American demonstration scene.

Considering the ongoing failure of the world’s media to produce anything resembling an accurate picture of Japan, the negative images of this country held by the public at large elsewhere should be no surprise.

And considering the nature of the news media itself–which presents little more than entertainment for people with an interest in current events–this state of affairs is unlikely to ever improve.

11 Responses to “The media’s anti-Japan bias: Nothing new under the sun”

  1. john k said

    Ampanton

    I was told about your website by a friend of mine recently. I was told there is lots of good info and links, which indeed it does have. However, I didn’t realise that it was playing the same record over again and again, (based upon my short review of this website).

    So Japan is viewed differently by others, it is viewed in a way that is not to your expectations, it is not viewed in a way that you would like it to be nor is it viewed as you say, accurately.

    “….I present a picture of Japan sono mama—as it is. As in any country, the people and its customs range from the sublime to the silly, but this site will not be informed by the fashionable irony and ill-concealed sense of superiority that too frequently infects the foreigner’s view of Japan…..”

    So when you say –as it is-, if the comments by others are not as you see it being portrayed “as it is”, an implication that everyone is uneducated about Japan and not as educated or well-informed as you on the subject, i.e. a form of superiority. Factual or otherwise…

    But you don’t want any ill-concealed sense of superiority…so I’m confused what you’re trying to say? It is not ok for others to have poor opinions of Japan, but it is ok for you to have a poor opinion of their reporting, because you know better?

    What is wrong with pointing out the factual inaccuracies with actual evidence to the contrary and then let your readers decide which is the truth?…or does that run the risk of others forming an opinion that differs from your own?

    To me this seems more like a case of…”Father, Father, father…they are calling me names again at school..”…. “ok son, I’ll go tell the headmaster”.

    Everyone, every country, all over the world is misrepresented. Either deal with it or not. If you do….stop banging the same drum again and again (Unless it is a Kodo drum..then please continue).

    If you are preaching to the converted, why dress the same argument in different clothes everyday?

    If you are preaching to the “unbelievers”, then you should present the positive face of Japan and stop focusing on negative issues. The Japanese do not dwell on negative issues, so why do you?

    Negative press does no one any good…Japanese acolyte or not.

  2. desslok said

    Dude, this is Ampontan’s blog. He can choose whatever topic he wants. If you don’t like it, just quit reviewing, lol.

  3. bender said

    Negative press does no one any good…Japanese acolyte or not.

    I thought you said that any form of speech is fine.

  4. ponta said

    Negative press does no one any good, and it is still on-going and rampant: Anpontan is a rare figure who tries to correct it or present different perspectives. What harm rather than good does this project bring about ?

  5. HHHH said

    I really hope Ampontan will keep on his good job reporting Japan as it is, regardless of what some ignorant guy says about it.

  6. Chris B said

    God forbid someone disagrees….

    Are they crazy!!
    Those madmen!!! This blog is the word of GOD!!! Sweet mother Mary!! Questioning a blog post!! What the f__K??

    Dear Mr. Post maker,
    Can I please have my F__KING COOKIE NOW!!!!!

  7. ampontan said

    This blog is the word of GOD!!!

    My sentiments exactly, Chris B!

  8. Aceface said

    “But you don’t want any ill-concealed sense of superiority…so I’m confused what you’re trying to say? It is not ok for others to have poor opinions of Japan, but it is ok for you to have a poor opinion of their reporting, because you know better?”

    I’m confused what you’re trying to say here too,John K.It’s called criticism.
    This is a blog run by William Sakovich and it is run in a manner as the way it is run in billions of blog in the blogsphere.Bill is simply writing what he think of subject he thinks he happens to know better than the others.

    If you have any objection,try some counterargument.

    “This sadly is very true in Japan. Since to express an opinion, publicly, that opposes the “norm” or the “masses” is considered rude and negative. That is why politics never moves forward here, they just agree to agree with each other, albeit slightly differently, so no one is upset. There is no real heated open debate.”

    Your words,not mine.

    Chris B:

    Is this the same Chris B I know from Neomarxisme?If so,good see you buddy.

  9. Aceface said

    Good idea that you delete that post from Neomarxisme,Bill.
    Marxy had intended to have an irony piece in relation with Nakayama’s statement over comfort women “denial”.I thought it was rather ill intended and misleading so I objeced.

  10. kei & yuri said

    This is our favorite new blog.
    Japanese businessmen probably started out golfing with katana but stopped once they realized that you lose a lot of balls that way.
    [rim shot]

  11. Aceface said

    Change the “Japanese businessmen”to “Western Expats” and “Golfing” into “playing catch” and “Katana” into “12 gauge shotgun” would be more like my take of the arguments,Kei&Yuri.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>