AMPONTAN

Japan from the inside out

Kim Jong-il: Growing senile?

Posted by ampontan on Sunday, September 23, 2007

THIS STORY IS FLYING SO LOW under the radar, it makes me suspect that people who follow North Korea more closely than I do might not be taking it seriously.

The Daily NK reported on the 20th that a Japanese source confirmed a story American intelligence heard about a year ago: North Korean leader Kim Jong-il is starting to suffer from dementia.

According to the source, “The U.S. official obtained intelligence that Kim Jong Il is suffering from symptom of dementia since a year ago. Such news is a top-secret subject which only the most important figures in North Korea’s seat of power know.”
However, the source relayed, “The U.S. official said, they do not currently know whether Kim Jong Il’s symptom is Alzheimer or senile dementia.”

The report notes that Kim makes policy decisions by personally approving reports that are submitted to him, but some people in his inner circle concerned about his behavior have begun to bypass Kim and ratify those reports on their own.

They also report that Kim can go on inspection tours and will meet with South Korean President Kim Moo-hyun during the Inter-Korea summit as scheduled on October 2-4, but his aides are concerned because they “do not know what he will say and cannot control what kind of strange behaviors he will display.”

Secretive dictatorships such as the Kim Family Regime are hotbeds for the germination of overblown rumors, so the story might have no basis in fact. The DPRK website is the place to go for news on North Korea, and they haven’t mentioned it. Neither has The Marmot, unless I missed it. It might be that everyone is focused on the upcoming summit and North Korea’s connection with the recent Israeli raid in Syria.

Even if this is nothing but a rumor, however, it does compel one to consider the gruesome possibilities of what might occur if it were true, or were ever to come to pass. Kim is 65, which is a bit early for either Alzheimer’s or senile dementia. Then again, this is a man who by all accounts has lived a profligate life, and was at one time the world’s largest consumer of Hennessey’s. It is also not too early for people both inside and outside North Korea to begin thinking of who will succeed him.

Contingency plans may already be in place. It would not be out of the question for rough preparations to have already been made for dealing with a sudden death by heart attack or stroke, or a more drawn-out terminal illness.

It is not as likely, however, that people in the inner circle have considered their options if Kim slowly but inexorably grew mentally incompetent. Considering the Dear Leader’s behavior over the years and his seemingly supreme power, it is not pleasant to speculate on the potential occurrence of some disturbing events as he slips into a twilight world. (Was he serious about ordering those executions? The distribution of funds? Will he forget tomorrow, or will he execute us if we delay?)

The character, or lack of it, of the people around him would become just as important as his physical and mental condition.

And then we could start to think about what might happen if he turned his attention to South Korea and Japan one day, somehow thought it was 1975 again, and happened to be in a particularly petulant mood.

About these ads

8 Responses to “Kim Jong-il: Growing senile?”

  1. Overthinker said

    It’s a cheap shot, but “starting” to suffer from dementia?

    Also I am slightly suspicious of claims that Kim is actually allowed to rule. Probably too used to Japanese Imperial-type rule, but I can’t help feeling that Kim’s main role is to act as a deity and focus of nationalism while the people and groups his father put in power wield the actual reins of government.

  2. Aceface said

    ”Probably too used to Japanese Imperial-type rule”

    I don’t think North Korea is run by pre-war Japanese style Imperial authoritalianism.I first read Gregory Henderson was mentioning that in forword of the Japanese translation of”Korea,The Politics of Voltex”,but I thought Juche ideoligy is a mixture of Stalinism and Mao cult from Cultural Revolution days and Korean style of confucianism.Anyway most of the follower of NK autocrat have never lived in colonial Korea nor Imperial Japan.Those who acted as communist or independence activist in Japan and colonial Korea had been purged in the 50′s and 60′s.So anyone who has first hand experience of Japanese emperor worship ideology were gone long before Kim Jong Il got to the power.
    I think the foreigners had been influenced too much with the resemblence they see in war time allied propaganda film on Imperial Japan and current North Korean propaganda television.

  3. Overthinker said

    Aceface – what I meant by that statement was just the the official leader is more of a façade or a puppet, not the full government system. That’s all. No direct connection, just a similar way of true power being behind the scenes with the leader more as a locus of patriotism and loyalty.

  4. GI Korea said

    There have been reports coming out all summer about Kim Jong-il’s health and the fact his oldest son returned from exile in Macau this summer as well has only wratched up the speculation.

    http://rokdrop.com/2007/08/28/kim-jong-nam-back-in-pyongyang/

    In fact last year China was even reportedly back his oldest son to take over as well.

    http://rokdrop.com/2006/12/18/china-backs-kim-jong-nam-as-nk-successor/

    All this specualtion could very well mean that he is suffering from some kind of sickness but there is no way to know if it is alzheimers or not. However, he is not meeting Roh at the airport for the summit and is allowing his second in command to handle the meeting with Roh. The only time Kim may meet Roh is at the propaganda festival they have set up for him with the children dancers.

    This lack of interaction with Roh could be interpreted as meaning that he is not all that healthy right now.

  5. ampontan said

    China’s backing the oldest son? The one who was caught in Tokyo going to Disneyland?

    Talk about a puppet regime!

  6. Aceface said

    Tell you what,the dude can speak English,Mandarin and some Japanese.Could be a likely candidate for the future North Korea.

    I think Kim just wants to keep distance from Roh after he saw the recent fake academic record scandal and the summit won’t gain any popularity for Roh.

  7. GI Korea said

    Puppet regime indeed. Where is Team America? :)

  8. bender said

    Team America is in Afghanistan and Iraq…and maybe Iran. Gotta call the People’s Liberation Army for help instead.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 109 other followers

%d bloggers like this: